Butler County Italian Restaurants
Butler County is home to dozens of delicious Italian dining options to satisfy every palate! Made from the freshest and finest ingredients, these staple dining establishments are sure to become your new favorite. Enjoy spaghetti, fettuccine alfredo, lasagna, baked ziti, and many other popular dishes to delight your tastebuds. Let these delicious restaurants be your passport to Italian cuisine you won't forget!
Andiamo Artisan Bakery
346 N 3rd St. Hamilton OH 45011Location: Hamilton
Head to Andiamo for authentic Italian and international specialties! Try their signature Sicilian almond paste cookies or dig into a cannoli filled with a house-made ricotta cheese mixture. Fruit cakes are available for the holidays and Andiamo offers a variety of other cookies and pastries.
Calabria Pizza
1010 Main Street Hamilton OH 45013Location: Hamilton
Calabria Pizza offers signature New York-style pizzas with homemade dough and Grande cheese. Popular menu items include meat lovers, bruschetta, and white pizza with ricotta and spinach, as well as calzones, salads, and a four-way pasta dish.
Carmagnola
24 S. 3rd Street Hamilton OH 45011Location: Hamilton
This modern Italian steakhouse with a farm-to-table focus will open in downtown Hamilton in spring 2025.
Caruso's Ristorante & Bar
6765 Dixie Hwy. Fairfield OH 45014Location: Fairfield
Treat yourself to Caruso's inspired Italian cuisine. Caruso's is known for serving Italian cuisine from all regions of Italy inspired from their travels. On the menu you can find feature American-Italian dishes, along with dishes with a special twist.
Fairfield Pizza & Pasta Company
680 Nilles Rd. Fairfield OH 45014Location: Fairfield
Fairfield Pizza & Pasta Company has been a Fairfield favorite since 1979 for salads, pasta, sandwiches, desserts, and of course, pizza! This is a small family-owned business with a very attentive and inviting staff. Come on in and catch up with friends or family over a scrumptious, affordable meal.
Gina's Italian Kitchen
1005 Eaton Ave. Hamilton OH 45013Location: Hamilton
In the mood for Italian? Gina's Italian Kitchen delights diners with their traditional family recipes, passed down for generations. Some menu favorites include the hoagies, pastas and pizzas. Don't miss the daily dessert specials! Photos courtesy of Gina's Italian Kitchen's Facebook page.
Paesano's Pasta House
308 S. Campus Ave. Oxford OH 45056Location: Oxford
Oxford's premier Italian restaurant. One of the most popular menu items is Choose a Pasta. Guests can decide on a pasta, sauce, meat or seafood and veggies to customize their own culinary creation. The ambiance and delectable Italian cuisine will leave you satisfied.
Primo Italian Steakhouse
6 South Broad St. Middletown OH 45044Location: Middletown
Primo Italian Steakhouse is an Italian steakhouse that offers a dining room, bar, outdoor patio, and exclusive speakeasy-style lounge.
Richard's Pizza
855 West State St. Trenton OH 45067Location: Trenton
Great taste since 1955, Richard's Pizza and Famous Steak Sandwich has been serving generations of families. They offer a wide variety of items including specialty pizzas, famous Italian Steak Sandwiches, delicious spaghetti dinners and more.
Richard's Pizza
495 Nilles Rd. Fairfield OH 45014Location: Fairfield
Great taste since 1955, Richard's Pizza and Famous Steak Sandwich has been serving generations of families. They offer a wide variety of items including specialty pizzas, famous Italian Steak Sandwiches, delicious spaghetti dinners and more.